How to find the right therapist in Fishers, IN

When choosing a therapist in Fishers, IN, it's best to reflect on what you’re looking for and ask yourself which of the following criteria are most important to you: Do they accept your insurance? Do you need a therapist who specializes in a specific mental health concern such as depression, anxiety, or trauma? Are you looking for someone to work with you individually? Or are you looking for someone to support you as a couple or family? Would you be more comfortable partnering with a therapist of a certain race, gender expression, sexual orientation, religious, or cultural background?

Can I use my insurance?

Yes! Therapists on the Rula platform are in-network with most major insurance plans. Rula patients typically pay $15 per session, although your individual cost may vary based on your insurance benefits and deductible. We’ll work with your insurance to confirm your estimated per-session cost before your first appointment. Ready to get started? Click here to browse available therapists who accept your insurance.

How do I know if therapy is right for me?

There’s no right or wrong reason to start therapy. Whether you’re seeking help navigating a life transition or managing symptoms of anxiety or depression, therapy is an effective treatment for many types of concerns – all you need is an open mind and a general sense of what you’d like to explore with a therapist. Still unsure? Head to our blog to learn more.

How soon can I meet with a therapist?

Therapists in Rula’s network are available to meet as soon as tomorrow. Click here to explore therapists and book your first session in minutes.

What should I consider when choosing a therapist?

It depends on your personal preferences and goals. Whether you’re seeking a therapist who specializes in certain mental health conditions, shares your ethnic background, or is available to meet at your preferred time – Rula makes it easy to search and filter by what matters most to you. If you don’t feel like your first choice was a match, don’t worry – we’ll help you switch to a different therapist in our network. Check out our blog post for more pointers on finding your best-fit therapist.

How do I know if I need therapy or psychiatry?

If you’re experiencing severe symptoms that interfere with your daily functioning, you may want to consider starting with a psychiatric provider who can assess your needs and prescribe medication if deemed necessary. If your symptoms are mild or moderate, therapy may be a better starting point. No matter where you begin your journey – your provider will work with you to develop a personalized treatment plan that’s based on your individual needs and concerns. Still unsure? Visit our blog to learn more about the differences.

Does Rula offer in-person appointments?

Currently, Rula offers in-person therapy in some states. For those living in other states, there are many benefits to online therapy!

Can Rula help me find a therapist?

Absolutely. Rula’s network of 10,000+ licensed providers represent more than 80 clinical specialties and a diverse range of backgrounds – making it easier to find the care you need. Once you provide us with some basic information, we’ll generate a curated list of in-network therapists who are licensed in your state and accepting new patients. From there, you can filter by what matters most to you and explore individual biographies until you find a match. Ready to get started?

What types of care can I access through Rula?

Providers in Rula’s network specialize in individual therapy, couples therapy, family therapy, and psychiatric care (i.e., medication management).

Who is eligible to access care through Rula?

Individuals aged 5 and older are eligible to receive care in any state where Rula is available.

How will I meet with my therapist?

Rula specializes in online therapy – giving you the flexibility to meet with your therapist from wherever you’re most comfortable. We’ll send you an appointment reminder containing a secure link to your scheduled Zoom session approximately 24 hours before your session.

Connect with Anxiety therapists in Fishers, IN

Need help? 323-745-8323

Quality care comes first at Rula

We regularly review providers to ensure quality

43 therapists

Jonathan Rex

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LMHC

•

2+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Jonathan Rex, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Jonathan has a Master of Clinical Health Services from Grace College.

Indiana

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Grief

Style

Exploratory

Spiritual

Supportive

Seeking counseling can be difficult, but the connection with your counselor matters most in creating change. I prioritize cultivating that connection by gathering your perspective and exploring how you'd like to see things change. Whether your picture of the future is clear or not, I hope to join you in your journey toward a more abundant life.

Next appointmentTomorrow

Available virtually

Traci Elliot

LMHC

•

11+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Traci Elliot, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Traci has a Master of Arts (MA) in Marriage and Family Therapy from Christian Theological Seminary.

Indianapolis, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Addiction

Depression

Trauma and PTSD

Style

Exploratory

Spiritual

Collaborative

I am a Licensed Mental Health Counselor who has a master's degree in Marriage and Family Therapy. I understand the importance of feeling balanced in and with all aspects of life. When we feel unbalanced, it can lead to increased struggles and challenges.

Next appointmentFriday, Oct 2nd

Available virtually

Lisa Johnson

LMHC

•

4+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Lisa Johnson, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Lisa has a Master's in Counseling (MC) in Mental Health Counseling from Walden University.

Indiana

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Family Conflict

Relationship Issues

Style

Responsive

Warm

Curious

I utilize a client-centered approach and specialize in addressing family issues, relationship challenges, parenting concerns, childhood issues, anxiety, depression, and difficulties adjusting to life stressors.

Next appointmentTomorrow

Available virtually

Patrick Hoekstra

LCSW

•

4+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Patrick Hoekstra, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Patrick has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Grand Valley State University.

Brownsburg, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Trauma and PTSD

Style

Outcome-oriented

Spiritual

Collaborative

I primarily utilize Cognitive Behavioral Therapy approaches as I feel they help the client achieve their goals quickly by changing how we think about external stimuli.

Next appointmentTomorrow

Available virtually

Isabel West

LMHC

•

9+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Isabel West, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Isabel has a Master's in Counseling (MC) from Chicago School of Professional Psychology.

Valparaiso, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Bipolar Disorder

Depression

Life Transitions

Stress

Style

Responsive

Approachable

Collaborative

I work with adolescents, teens, and adults and specialize in anxiety, stress, depression, and bipolar disorder using a Client-Centered Approach and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy.

Next appointmentTomorrow

Available virtually

Lindsay Starlin

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW

•

12+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Lindsay Starlin, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Lindsay has a Master of Social Work (MSW) in Mental Health/Addictions from Indiana University -Purdue University Indianapolis.

Plainfield, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Grief

Stress

Style

Outcome-oriented

Attuned

Collaborative

I specialize in anxiety and depression, trauma, grief and loss, stress, work-related issues, and marital and relationship counseling.

Next appointmentMonday, Oct 5th

Available virtually

Kari Evans

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW

•

12+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Kari Evans, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Kari has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis.

Indiana

Specialties

Anxiety

Addiction

Alcohol Use

Depression

Grief

Style

Outcome-oriented

Approachable

Affirming

I value the human experience and want to partner with you to be your best self.

Next appointmentWednesday, Oct 7th

Available virtually

Charlotte Barton Coombs

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LCSW

•

3+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Charlotte Barton Coombs, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Charlotte has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis.

Columbus, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Life Transitions

Stress

Style

Exploratory

Candid

Affirming

I specialize in helping individuals navigate anxiety, depression, and life transitions using evidence-based approaches like Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Dialectical Behavioral Therapy, and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy.

Next appointmentFriday, Sep 25th

Available virtually

Sara Black

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LCSW

•

1+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Sara Black, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sara has a Master of Social Work (MSW) in Clinical Social Work from University of Southern California.

Bloomington, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Autism or Asperger's Syndrome

Obsessive-Compulsive (OCD)

Panic Attacks

Trauma and PTSD

Style

Exploratory

Candid

Collaborative

I offer an interactive and genuinely collaborative space. You will find me to be straightforward, and easy to talk to. I'm happy to schedule a consultation to chat about your needs and expectations, and whether I might be a good match to support your journey toward greater well-being.

Next appointmentWednesday, Sep 23rd

Available virtually

Leslie Cain

LCSW

•

2+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Leslie Cain, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Leslie has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from IUPUI.

Columbus, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Coping Skills

Depression

Life Transitions

Self Esteem

Style

Exploratory

Gentle

Collaborative

I work with clients on healing from anxiety, depression, and trauma through EMDR, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, Motivational Interviewing, and Dialectical Behavior Therapy.

Next appointmentWednesday, Sep 23rd

Available virtually

Christina Zivec

LMHC

•

2+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Christina Zivec, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Christina has a Master of Arts (MA) in Clinical Psychology from Illinois School of Professional Psychology.

Marion, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Gender Identity

LGBTQIA+

Style

Exploratory

Approachable

Affirming

I'm committed to supporting individuals on their journey toward healing and personal growth. My approach is compassionate, client-centered, and rooted in evidence-based practices to help navigate life's challenges. I strive to create a safe and empowering space for you to explore emotions and build resilience.

Next appointmentThursday, Sep 24th

Available virtually

Margaret Abrell

Patients consistently give high satisfaction ratings

LCSW

•

5+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Margaret Abrell, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Margaret has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University, Purdue University Indianapolis.

Indiana

Specialties

Anxiety

Adoption

Trauma and PTSD

Style

Outcome-oriented

Approachable

Motivational

I support individuals navigating complex life transitions and challenges. As an adoption-competent therapist, I understand the unique experiences that come with adoption and family dynamics.

Next appointmentThursday, Sep 24th

Available virtually

Angela Miller

LCSW

•

1+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Angela Miller, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Angela has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Western New Mexico University.

Indiana

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Grief

Style

Responsive

Approachable

Collaborative

I work with adolescents and adults navigating depression, work-related stress, grief, and anxiety.

Next appointmentTomorrow

Available virtually

Sharika Gardner Spates

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW

•

4+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Sharika Gardner Spates, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sharika has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Georgia.

Indiana

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Panic Attacks

Stress

Style

Exploratory

Warm

Curious

I help adults navigate anxiety, depression, stress, and relationship struggles.

Next appointmentMonday, Oct 5th

Available virtually

Rita Polivick

LCSW

•

31+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Rita Polivick, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Rita has a Master of Science (MS) from St. Francis College.

Fort Wayne, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Bipolar Disorder

Depression

Grief

Mood Disorders

Style

Responsive

Warm

Collaborative

I have distinguished myself through decades of professional experience. I practiced in hospital, residential, and outpatient settings.

Next appointmentFriday, Oct 2nd

Available virtually

Jayme Battaglia Jennings

LCSW

•

3+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Jayme Battaglia Jennings, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Jayme has a Master of Social Work (MSW) in Child and Family Therapy from Roberts Wesleyan College.

Jeffersonville, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Panic Attacks

Stress

Trauma and PTSD

Style

Exploratory

Approachable

Supportive

I am passionate about working with others to overcome anxiety and stress-related symptoms.

Next appointmentFriday, Oct 2nd

Available virtually

Sonja Lingo

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LMHC

•

16+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Sonja Lingo, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sonja has a Master of Arts (MA) in Counseling Psychology from Ball State University.

Fort Wayne, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Depression

Grief

Trauma and PTSD

Style

Outcome-oriented

Warm

Collaborative

Whether you're seeking therapy for the first time or continuing your healing journey, I'm proud of you for prioritizing your well-being. Counseling is my passion, and I'm honored you're considering this journey with me. I specialize in treating trauma and help clients navigate many of life's difficulties.

Next appointmentFriday, Oct 16th

Available virtually

Sarah Serles

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LMHC

•

1+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Sarah Serles, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sarah has a Masters of Arts (MA) in Mental Health Counseling from Purdue University.

Michigan City, IN

Specialties

Anxiety

Addiction

Depression

Substance Use

Style

Outcome-oriented

Warm

Supportive

I have been working in the field for 7 years, mainly with clients struggling with depression, anxiety, and addiction.

Next appointmentMonday, Oct 5th

Available virtually

This set of providers was curated just for you.

Want personalized assistance finding the right fit? Call or text our team at 323-745-8323.

Previous providers

From our blog

View article

“Using small but frequent mindfulness strategies can make a big impact over time. For example, the next time you’re eating, take a bite, and pull your focus inward. Try to chew slowly and taste what you’re eating. Try to relax your body and notice how you’re feeling. This simple exercise can last a few seconds, but, over time, it can make being present feel more accessible.”

– Ashley Ayala, LMFT

View article

“If a client told me they often cry when they feel overwhelmed, even if they can’t pinpoint a specific reason, I’d explore whether anxiety might be the cause. Feeling like your emotions build up until they spill over is tough, but you don’t have to manage it alone. There are ways to find relief and support.”

– Brandy Chalmers, LPC

View article

“If anxiety seems random, try noting what happened just before — who you were with, how you felt, and if you overrode any personal boundaries. Often, hidden triggers come from subtle discomforts or internal conflicts that aren't obvious in the moment. Therapy can be a powerful space to explore these patterns, helping you build awareness and respond with more clarity and self-compassion.”

– Ashley Ayala, LMFT

Hundreds of thousands of patients have found affordable, in-network mental health care with Rula

Insurance

After you select a provider, we’ll send you a personalized cost estimate before your first session—so you’ll know what to expect.

$15 / session

typical cost patients pay through Rula

Nationwide coverage:

After you select a provider, we’ll send you a personalized cost estimate before your first session—so you’ll know what to expect.

100+ insurance plans accepted

140M total lives covered

Millions of sessions completed

Network

We hold providers to high clinical standards so you can trust the care you receive.

15,000+

licensed providers

Match

The right provider makes all the difference. We help you find someone who truly fits your needs—the first time.

98%

of searches result in an exact match

Progress

Care should make a difference. Our approach helps you track progress you can feel.

93%

of patients report feeling better after treatment through Rula

Additional therapy specialties and modalities

Sex Therapy Trauma and PTSD Anxiety EMDR Dialectical (DBT)

Psychiatry Couples Family Children therapy Preteen therapy Teen therapy

Male therapists Female therapists Spanish-speaking therapists Black or African American therapists Asian therapists Hispanic or Latinx therapists

Find a therapist near you

South Bend Anderson Bloomington Carmel Columbus Elkhart Evansville Fishers Fort Wayne Gary Greenwood Hammond Indianapolis Jeffersonville Kokomo Lafayette Muncie Noblesville Terre Haute Westfield

Understanding online therapy for anxiety

Anxiety and its impact on mental health

Anxiety is a natural response to stress that can create feelings of worry, nervousness, or unease about certain events or situations. While occasional anxiety is normal, excessive or constant anxiety may interfere with your daily activities, work, and relationships. This can impact your quality of life and negatively affect your physical and emotional well-being.

Importance of seeking therapy for anxiety

Seeking therapy can be important if you’re struggling with anxiety. Your therapists can help identify the root causes of your anxiety and provide strategies to manage your symptoms. Early intervention can also help prevent the development of more severe anxiety disorders and reduce the risk of developing other mental health issues. Therapy for anxiety can help improve your overall well-being, self-esteem, and your ability to cope with life's challenges.

Common therapeutic approaches for anxiety

Therapists use several therapeutic approaches to address specific aspects of anxiety. For example:

Potential benefits of online therapy for anxiety

Online therapy for anxiety presents several potential benefits that often make it a more appealing choice compared to in-person therapy. It eliminates logistical challenges, enabling you to connect with licensed therapists throughout your state, even if they’re not in your local area. With online therapy, scheduling sessions become more flexible, fitting into your daily routine. Additionally, participating in therapy sessions from the comfort of your home can enhance feelings of safety, privacy, and comfort.

Tips for choosing an anxiety therapist

FAQs about anxiety therapy and anxiety therapists

When should I seek treatment for anxiety?

If anxiety symptoms often disrupt your daily life or cause intense distress, you may benefit from professional treatment. Some signs that anxiety has become problematic include excessive worrying, constant nervousness, physical symptoms like a racing heart or shortness of breath, sleep issues, or avoiding certain situations. Seeking help early on can prevent anxiety from worsening into a more severe disorder and improve mental health overall. Therapy provides a supportive environment to get to the root of your anxiety, build healthy coping strategies, and learn techniques to keep symptoms under control.

How long does anxiety therapy typically last?

The duration of anxiety therapy depends on several factors – the severity of your symptoms, how quickly you improve, and the methods used by your therapist. Anxiety therapy may last a few weeks to several months or may continue for over a year. Your therapist should review your progress and adjust your treatment as needed to ensure the best approach for you.

What should I expect during my first anxiety therapy session?

In your first anxiety therapy session, your therapist may ask about your history, symptoms, and goals for treatment. You and your therapist should also discuss their recommended therapy approach, confidentiality, and expectations. During this initial visit, you’ll be able to ask many questions and establish rapport with your new therapist!

How do I know if a therapist is qualified to treat anxiety disorders?

Qualified anxiety therapists typically hold a degree in psychology, social work, or a related field, and have a license to practice in your state. Look for therapists with experience treating anxiety disorders and other relevant certifications, such as specialized training in cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT).

Will my insurance cover the cost of anxiety therapy sessions?

Insurance coverage for anxiety therapy varies by provider and plan. After you've booked your first session, Rula verifies your insurance coverage and follows up with a cost estimate, including any required copayments.

Can anxiety therapy be done online or through teletherapy?

Yes! Anxiety therapy can be done online via video calls. Rula offers online therapy for increased accessibility, convenience, and comfort for many people seeking help for anxiety.

Connect with Anxiety therapists in Fishers, IN

Quality care comes first at Rula

Jonathan Rex

Traci Elliot

Lisa Johnson

Patrick Hoekstra

Isabel West

Lindsay Starlin

Kari Evans

Charlotte Barton Coombs

Sara Black

Leslie Cain

Christina Zivec

Margaret Abrell

Angela Miller

Sharika Gardner Spates

Rita Polivick

Jayme Battaglia Jennings

Sonja Lingo

Sarah Serles

From our blog

Hundreds of thousands of patients have found affordable, in-network mental health care with Rula

Insurance

$15 / session

Network

15,000+

Match

98%

Progress

93%

Additional therapy specialties and modalities

Find a therapist near you

We’re here when you need us

We’re here when you need us

Here to help