Connect with Therapists who accept Aetna in Fishers, IN

Quality care comes first at Rula

We regularly review providers to ensure quality

50+ therapists
A headshot image of Katherine Feldmeier

Katherine Feldmeier

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
11+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Katherine Feldmeier, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Katherine has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Southern Indiana.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Relationship Issues
Style
Exploratory
Attuned
Curious

Life can sometimes feel overwhelming, and finding peace, confidence, and joy might seem like a distant dream. But it's possible, and I am ready to help you on this journey.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Joy Bell

Joy Bell

LMHC
23+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Joy Bell, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Joy has a Master of Science (MS) from University of Saint Francis.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Mood Disorders
Stress
Style
Directive
Approachable
Supportive

I have been working in mental health since 2003 and have a lot of experience with various populations.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Amie Stefanich

Amie Stefanich

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LCSW
14+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Amie Stefanich, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Amie has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Loyola University Chicago, Stritch School of Medicine.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Life Transitions
Stress
Style
Directive
Attuned
Collaborative

I help individuals navigate life's challenges with empathy and support. Whether you're facing a major transition, feeling overwhelmed, or seeking personal growth, I provide a safe and compassionate space for healing and change.

Amy gives thoughtful feedback and is a great listener. She helps put my problems in perspective and provides helpful solutions.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Kirsten Donaldson

Kirsten Donaldson

LMHC
3+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Kirsten Donaldson, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Kirsten has a Master in Counseling (MC) Community Counseling from Bradley University.

Franklin, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Self Esteem
Stress
Style
Directive
Approachable
Collaborative

Do you think you are not good enough, you are a failure, or have another negative belief about yourself? Those come from past experiences, and EMDR can help you process past events and develop more positive beliefs. I am trained in EMDR and DBT and can help with negative beliefs, regulating emotions, and improving relationships.

Available virtually

A headshot image of David Kolker

David Kolker

LCSW
11+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like David Kolker, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

David has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Florida Atlantic University.

Indianapolis, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Infidelity
Relationship Issues
Sexual Addiction
Substance Use
Style
Insightful
Candid
Collaborative

I am glad you're here. I'm a therapist—and more importantly, a real person who genuinely wants to help. Reaching out isn't easy, but I'm so glad you did. I come from a clinical approach of Attachment Theory, whereby we will see how childhood issues have shaped who we are today.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Katherine Bowers

Katherine Bowers

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
16+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Katherine Bowers, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Katherine has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Western Michigan University.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Relationship Issues
Style
Responsive
Warm
Affirming

I specialize in the treatment of individuals struggling with a variety of issues, including depression, anxiety, identity and development, and life transitions. Taking the first step to sign up for therapy can take courage, and I am proud of you for getting started!

Available virtually

A headshot image of Shani Nealy

Shani Nealy

Recognized for high quality patient care

LMFT
5+ years

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (LMFTs), like Shani Nealy, are mental health professionals trained in family systems who can diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Shani has a Master of Human Relations from University of Oklahoma.

Indiana
Specialties
Career Counseling
Peer Relationships
Relationship Issues
Stress
Weight Loss
Style
Outcome-oriented
Approachable
Collaborative

I believe therapy develops into an intellectual conversation about emotions, patterns and changes. In our sessions, you can expect real conversation — not just coping tips, but genuine exploration of what's keeping you stuck.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Carl Quedenfeld

Carl Quedenfeld

LMHC
32+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Carl Quedenfeld, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Carl has a Master of Arts (MA) Addiction Studies from Indiana Wesleyan University and a Master of Arts (MA) Counseling from Northern Illinois University.

Indiana
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Relationship Issues
Substance Use
Style
Practical
Candid
Curious

I am a Licensed Professional Counselor. I have spent the last 44 years in the field of mental health and substance use doing direct service, supervision, management, and consulting. I have training and skills in a variety of evidence-based treatments, including the Gottman Method for relationships, DBT, CBT, Exposure therapy, and other modalities.

Available virtually

A headshot image of L. Colleen Mccarthy

L. Colleen Mccarthy

LMFT
10+ years

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (LMFTs), like L. Colleen Mccarthy, are mental health professionals trained in family systems who can diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

L. Colleen has a Masters of Education (MED) from Indiana University Purdue University Fort Wayne.

Angola, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Mood Disorders
Stress
Style
Insightful
Attuned
Empowering

You are beginning an exciting internal journey toward enhanced contentment and joy! I'm honored to walk with you. Great therapy should look like a lovely conversation between friends with some amazing science and skills mixed in.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Elizabeth Forbes

Elizabeth Forbes

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LCSW
2+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Elizabeth Forbes, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Elizabeth has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis.

Columbus, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Domestic Violence
Life Transitions
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Approachable
Empowering

You are so brave to take this step to take care of yourself. You matter, you qualify, and you are worthy. My philosophy is: if each of us is better, then all of us are better. I work to meet you right where you are, and from there, we explore where you want to go.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Andrew Visco

Andrew Visco

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LCSW
3+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Andrew Visco, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Andrew has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University School of Social Work.

Indianapolis, IN
Specialties
Gender Identity
LGBTQIA+
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Warm
Collaborative

I am curious, open-minded, non-paternalistic, and thoughtful. I use metacognitive and narrative approaches to help you think about your thinking so that you can build mastery strategies to tackle your psychological problems. I strive to provide a warm and compassionate atmosphere for clients of all backgrounds.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Erika Fadahunsi Lizardo

Erika Fadahunsi Lizardo

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
8+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Erika Fadahunsi Lizardo, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Erika has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Clark Atlanta University.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Relationship Issues
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Insightful
Approachable
Affirming

I'm deeply committed to helping individuals, couples, and families navigate life's complexities. I specialize in working with families, adults, teenagers, and couples. I'm passionate about helping clients improve communication, resolve conflicts, and foster healthier relationships.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Jessica C. Rodriguex

Jessica C. Rodriguex

LMFT
2+ years

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (LMFTs), like Jessica C. Rodriguex, are mental health professionals trained in family systems who can diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Jessica C. has a Master in Counseling (MC) in counseling from Northwestern University.

Indiana
Specialties
ADHD
Addiction
Anxiety
Autism or Asperger's Syndrome
Substance Use
Style
Exploratory
Candid
Supportive

I work with adolescents, young adults, and adults facing complex challenges including the mental health effects of incarceration and rebuilding life afterward. I support family members of those struggling with addiction or incarceration, and parents of children with behavioral issues.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Teri Cardwell

Teri Cardwell

LCSW
33+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Teri Cardwell, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Teri has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Substance Use
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Directive
Candid
Curious

I believe in building a respectful, collaborative therapy relationship to help you achieve your highest and best self. I encourage you to honor yourself and your life story in order to live in the present and reach for the future. Personal growth is achieved by developing your strengths and learning new skills on life's journey.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Marlene Scott-Bruner

Marlene Scott-Bruner

LCSW
4+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Marlene Scott-Bruner, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Marlene has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University Northwest.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Trauma and PTSD
Women's Issues
Style
Outcome-oriented
Candid
Collaborative

I work with adolescents and adults seeking not only symptom relief, but also deeper understanding and meaningful change. Together, we'll identify patterns that no longer serve you, build practical coping tools, and set goals that align with your values and the emotional life you want to experience—joy, peace, confidence, and connection.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Gianna Giovanello

Gianna Giovanello

LCSW
1+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Gianna Giovanello, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Gianna has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Simmons College.

Lafayette, IN
Specialties
Alcohol Use
Anxiety
Coping Skills
Depression
Substance Use
Style
Responsive
Approachable
Supportive

Have you been struggling with anxiety, depression, or substance use disorder? I can help you learn effective ways to manage life challenges without letting your mental health or substance use interfere with your well-being and goals.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Jarrett Langfitt

Jarrett Langfitt

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
6+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Jarrett Langfitt, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Jarrett has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Chicago.

Indiana
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Substance Use
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Warm
Curious

Whether you're struggling with sadness, worry, work stress, substance use, relationship difficulties, or emotions from traumatic experiences, I offer a supportive ear and nonjudgmental environment. Together we'll identify and implement strategies to move you toward your goals in a space characterized by compassion, acceptance, and safety.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Julie Brandenburg

Julie Brandenburg

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCP
14+ years

Licensed Clinical Psychologists (LCPs), like Julie Brandenburg, hold a doctoral degree and are trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Julie has a Doctor of Philosophy (PHD) Clinical Psychology from University of Missouri, Saint Louis.

Indiana
Specialties
Domestic Violence
Relationship Issues
Sexual Abuse
Trauma and PTSD
Women's Issues
Style
Insightful
Approachable
Collaborative

Beginning therapy is prioritizing your well-being as you navigate life. I work with adults living with difficulties like stress, anxiety, depression, trauma, and relationship challenges. I provide a non-judgmental space where you can share at your own pace. We will work together to discover the sources of your struggles and ways to manage them.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Branda-Lee Maurushes

Branda-Lee Maurushes

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
3+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Branda-Lee Maurushes, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Branda-Lee has a Master of Social Work (MSW) in Mental Health and Addictions from Indiana University Northwest.

Indiana
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Style
Directive
Attuned
Supportive

Life's stress is inevitable, but how we manage it makes all the difference. I'm here to support you toward peace and happiness. I work with adults experiencing anger management, anxiety, low self-esteem, depression, addiction, grief, unresolved childhood experiences, and relationship conflicts.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Sherrie Kleinholz

Sherrie Kleinholz

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LMFT
10+ years

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (LMFTs), like Sherrie Kleinholz, are mental health professionals trained in family systems who can diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sherrie has a Master in Counseling (MC) from Xavier University.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Stress
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Insightful
Spiritual
Curious

I am a LPCC‑S and LMHC who takes a collaborative, client‑driven approach to therapy. I specialize in OCD, panic disorder, mood disorders, and general mental health concerns. My style is practical, compassionate, and rooted in evidence‑based care. I am also able to provide Christian/Catholic perspectives if you so desire.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Ashley Peck

Ashley Peck

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LMHC
2+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Ashley Peck, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Ashley has a Master in Counseling (MC) from Liberty University.

Brownsburg, IN
Specialties
ADHD
Anxiety
Codependency
Relationship Issues
Stress
Style
Practical
Approachable
Collaborative

I am a board-certified LMHC in the state of Indiana. I use a person-centered approach to working with clients and implement CBT, Attachment Theory, and Mindfulness as well as other concepts and interventions. I enjoy working with teens and adults struggling with anxiety, depression, ADHD, and relationship issues.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Martin McCary

Martin McCary

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
2+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Martin McCary, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Martin has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana Wesleyan University.

Munster, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Men's Issues
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Responsive
Candid
Collaborative

I am a trauma-informed therapist working with children, adolescents, and adults. I help clients navigate anxiety, depression, trauma, and family challenges. I also run a psychosocial group for teen males that enhances their ability to succeed academically, socially, and emotionally.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Angel Babcock

Angel Babcock

Recognized for high quality patient care

LMHC
10+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Angel Babcock, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Angel has a Master of Arts (MA) in Mental Health Counseling from Tennessee Technological University.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Relationship Issues
Stress
Style
Practical
Approachable
Collaborative

I support individuals across a wide range of mental health concerns. With experience in residential, outpatient, and in-home settings, I create a warm space where you can explore challenges and build on your strengths.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Karen Fatouros

Karen Fatouros

Recognized for high quality patient care

LMHC
9+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Karen Fatouros, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Karen has a Master's in Counseling (MC) from Adler University.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
LGBTQIA+
Life Transitions
Style
Exploratory
Candid
Collaborative

I am a Licensed Mental Health Counselor (LMHC) and Licensed School Counselor, with additional certifications in substance abuse and hypnosis. I specialize in supporting adults through challenges like depression, anxiety, and life transitions. I also have a particular interest in working with LGBTQIA2S+ individuals & those within the school system.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Jennifer DeVore

Jennifer DeVore

LCSW
3+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Jennifer DeVore, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Jennifer has a Master of Science in Social Work (MSSW) from University of Louisville.

Indiana
Specialties
ADHD
Anxiety
Depression
Women's Issues
Style
Outcome-oriented
Approachable
Affirming

I work primarily with women and specialize in neurodivergent populations using Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, mindfulness, strengths-based approaches, and Narrative Therapy.

Available virtually

Continue exploring providers