Connect with Therapists who accept MagnaCare in Carmel, IN

Quality care comes first at Rula

We regularly review providers to ensure quality

50+ therapists
A headshot image of Sara Bucksten

Sara Bucksten

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LMFT
8+ years

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (LMFTs), like Sara Bucksten, are mental health professionals trained in family systems who can diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sara has a Master of Arts (MA) in Marriage/Family Therapy from Indiana Wesleyan University.

Westfield, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Relationship Issues
Style
Responsive
Attuned
Collaborative

I want to honor you by meeting you where you are and collaborating together to meet your needs and goals. I specialize in working with couples navigating life transitions, communication challenges, or betrayal. I also work with individuals during life transitions, experiencing anxiety, depression, or seeking purpose.

Available virtually and in person

A headshot image of Amy Kirkland

Amy Kirkland

LCSW
19+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Amy Kirkland, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Amy has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis.

Indianapolis, IN
Specialties
ADHD
Anxiety
Depression
Relationship Issues
Style
Responsive
Approachable
Collaborative

My goal is to assist my clients in navigating the challenges that life presents to each of us. Our minds can become stuck in the “on” position when we are overwhelmed by unexpected changes or disappointments in daily life. Life can become difficult. When our fear network is in overdrive, we can experience a wide range of negative emotions.

Available virtually and in person

A headshot image of Hiawatha Sanford

Hiawatha Sanford

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
10+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Hiawatha Sanford, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Hiawatha has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Mississippi.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Relationship Issues
Style
Responsive
Attuned
Supportive

I believe that everyone has strengths, and together we can identify those strengths and build on them.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Shannon Shore

Shannon Shore

LCSW
4+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Shannon Shore, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Shannon has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from East Carolina University.

Indiana
Specialties
ADHD
Anxiety
Autism or Asperger's Syndrome
Style
Insightful
Candid
Supportive

I worked with individuals with ADHD and anxious thinkers for over a decade. I take a strengths-based approach to learning how to work with your brain instead of against it. While working with me, you will learn practical skills to help you increase your self-confidence.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Sally Archer-Jones

Sally Archer-Jones

LCSW
4+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Sally Archer-Jones, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sally has a Doctor of Philosophy (PHD) in Social Work from Virginia Commonwealth University and a Master of Social Work from California State University.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Suicidal Ideation
Thought Disorders
Women's Issues
Style
Practical
Approachable
Collaborative

As a therapist, I focus on providing a safe and welcoming environment where my clients can work on creating solutions to the multiple stressors within their lives. My goal is to help clients meet their needs by using culturally responsive and evidence-based interventions.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Priscilla Huley

Priscilla Huley

Recognized for high quality patient care

LMHC
4+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Priscilla Huley, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Priscilla has a Master of Science (MS) in Clinical Counseling from Eastern Illinois University.

Highland, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Stress
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Gentle
Empowering

I work with adults and couples specializing in depression, anxiety, life transitions, stress, trauma, and alternative sexual lifestyles. Using trauma-focused, person-centered, solution-focused, cognitive-behavioral, and sex-positive approaches, I help you analyze your experiences and develop skills to cope with life's challenges.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Joscelyn Mathis

Joscelyn Mathis

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
1+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Joscelyn Mathis, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Joscelyn has a Master of Social Work (MSW) in Mental Health and Addictions / Leadership from Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
LGBTQIA+
Life Transitions
Relationship Issues
Style
Responsive
Warm
Collaborative

I help you navigate life's challenges with compassion, respect, and evidence-based care. I work with individuals, couples, and families, creating a safe and nonjudgmental space for healing, growth, and self-discovery. I specialize in supporting BIPOC, LGBTQ+ individuals, and those living with chronic health conditions.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Amy Hirt

Amy Hirt

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
7+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Amy Hirt, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Amy has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis.

Indianapolis, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Gender Identity
LGBTQIA+
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Responsive
Warm
Supportive

I serve clients with a holistic and compassionate approach to mental health. I believe in treating each client as an individual, employing a therapeutic toolbox tailored to your unique needs. My goal is to help you navigate your mental health journey with warmth and understanding.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Debra Buckner

Debra Buckner

LCSW
33+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Debra Buckner, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Debra has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Southern Mississippi.

Indiana
Specialties
Addiction
Alcohol Use
Coping Skills
Relapse Prevention
Substance Use
Style
Outcome-oriented
Gentle
Empowering

I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker with experience supporting individuals as they navigate life transitions, emotional challenges, and personal growth. I provide a compassionate, client-centered approach grounded in evidence-based practices and respect for each person’s unique story.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Cassia Iglesias

Cassia Iglesias

LCSW
16+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Cassia Iglesias, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Cassia has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Loyola University Chicago.

Indiana
Specialties
Codependency
Coping Skills
Self Esteem
Stress
Women's Issues
Style
Practical
Approachable
Empowering

I strive to help people find Wholeness. Strength in Mind, Body & Spirit. I believe you are the expert of your life, yet might need encouragement to find the tools to rebuild. I strive to edify my clients and focus on their innate strengths.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Elizabeth Forbes

Elizabeth Forbes

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LCSW
2+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Elizabeth Forbes, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Elizabeth has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis.

Columbus, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Domestic Violence
Life Transitions
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Approachable
Empowering

You are so brave to take this step to take care of yourself. You matter, you qualify, and you are worthy. My philosophy is: if each of us is better, then all of us are better. I work to meet you right where you are, and from there, we explore where you want to go.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Branda-Lee Maurushes

Branda-Lee Maurushes

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
3+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Branda-Lee Maurushes, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Branda-Lee has a Master of Social Work (MSW) in Mental Health and Addictions from Indiana University Northwest.

Indiana
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Style
Directive
Attuned
Supportive

Life's stress is inevitable, but how we manage it makes all the difference. I'm here to support you toward peace and happiness. I work with adults experiencing anger management, anxiety, low self-esteem, depression, addiction, grief, unresolved childhood experiences, and relationship conflicts.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Michael Patrick

Michael Patrick

Recognized for high quality patient care

LMHC
6+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Michael Patrick, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Michael has a Master of Business Administration (MBA) from Indiana Wesleyan University and a Master of Science Psychology (MSPSY) in Mental Health Counseling from Grace College Theological and Seminary.

Muncie, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Stress
Substance Use
Style
Outcome-oriented
Approachable
Collaborative

My approach to therapy is based on the belief that it is my responsibility to help clients feel comfortable and build trust. Life is hard, and therapy is a resource that can help individuals change their lives to live a healthier, more empowered lifestyle.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Katherine McHone

Katherine McHone

LCSW
16+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Katherine McHone, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Katherine has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis.

Fishers, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Responsive
Gentle
Collaborative

Taking the first step and seeking therapy can be overwhelming, and I am here to help make that first step as smooth as possible. I specialize in working with clients going through life transitions as well as anxiety, depression, and trauma. I provide a safe, supportive environment where you can begin the healing process.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Shani Nealy

Shani Nealy

Recognized for high quality patient care

LMFT
5+ years

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (LMFTs), like Shani Nealy, are mental health professionals trained in family systems who can diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Shani has a Master of Human Relations from University of Oklahoma.

Indiana
Specialties
Career Counseling
Peer Relationships
Relationship Issues
Stress
Weight Loss
Style
Outcome-oriented
Approachable
Collaborative

I believe therapy develops into an intellectual conversation about emotions, patterns and changes. In our sessions, you can expect real conversation — not just coping tips, but genuine exploration of what's keeping you stuck.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Mary Jo LaRose

Mary Jo LaRose

LCSW
15+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Mary Jo LaRose, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Mary Jo has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Denver.

Indianapolis, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Self Esteem
Stress
Style
Responsive
Warm
Collaborative

I have over 40 years of experience working in diverse settings. I believe that our past experiences and lifelong development shape how we perceive ourselves, our world, and our relationships with others. I find value in all individuals I encounter. I believe we all have innate gifts to discover within ourselves, leading to self-growth.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Sherrie Kleinholz

Sherrie Kleinholz

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LMFT
10+ years

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (LMFTs), like Sherrie Kleinholz, are mental health professionals trained in family systems who can diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sherrie has a Master in Counseling (MC) from Xavier University.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Stress
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Insightful
Spiritual
Curious

I am a LPCC‑S and LMHC who takes a collaborative, client‑driven approach to therapy. I specialize in OCD, panic disorder, mood disorders, and general mental health concerns. My style is practical, compassionate, and rooted in evidence‑based care. I am also able to provide Christian/Catholic perspectives if you so desire.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Bianca Cervantes

Bianca Cervantes

LMHC
4+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Bianca Cervantes, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Bianca has a Master of Arts (MA) in Clinical Psychology with Counseling Practice from Roosevelt University.

Indianapolis, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Bipolar Disorder
Depression
Spirituality
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Insightful
Warm
Collaborative

You deserve a space where you don't have to explain your culture, hide your emotions, or carry life's challenges by yourself. I help adults navigate anxiety, depression, stress, and life transitions with warmth, practical tools, and culturally responsive care in both English and Spanish. When you're ready, I'm here to support you.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Jann Monserrat

Jann Monserrat

LMFT
4+ years

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (LMFTs), like Jann Monserrat, are mental health professionals trained in family systems who can diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Jann has a Master of Science in Clinical Psychology from Antioch University Los Angeles.

Indiana
Specialties
Depression
Grief
Infidelity
Life Transitions
Relationship Issues
Style
Insightful
Warm
Empowering

I work with adults navigating life's challenges, transitions, and personal growth. I provide a supportive, nonjudgmental space where we can explore concerns such as anxiety, depression, stress, relationship difficulties, trauma, and life changes while working toward meaningful and lasting change.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Stephanie Milan

Stephanie Milan

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LCSW
5+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Stephanie Milan, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Stephanie has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Southern Indiana.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Self Esteem
Stress
Style
Responsive
Candid
Supportive

As a laid-back therapist, I prioritize creating a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere where clients feel safe to express themselves openly. My goal is to foster a space that encourages honest conversation and personal growth at each individual's pace.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Joy Bell

Joy Bell

LMHC
23+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Joy Bell, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Joy has a Master of Science (MS) from University of Saint Francis.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Mood Disorders
Stress
Style
Directive
Approachable
Supportive

I have been working in mental health since 2003 and have a lot of experience with various populations.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Jonathan Rex

Jonathan Rex

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LMHC
2+ years

Licensed Mental Health Counselors (LMHCs), like Jonathan Rex, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Jonathan has a Master of Clinical Health Services from Grace College.

Indiana
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Style
Exploratory
Spiritual
Supportive

Seeking counseling can be difficult, but the connection with your counselor matters most in creating change. I prioritize cultivating that connection by gathering your perspective and exploring how you'd like to see things change. Whether your picture of the future is clear or not, I hope to join you in your journey toward a more abundant life.

Available virtually

A headshot image of L. Colleen Mccarthy

L. Colleen Mccarthy

LMFT
10+ years

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (LMFTs), like L. Colleen Mccarthy, are mental health professionals trained in family systems who can diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

L. Colleen has a Masters of Education (MED) from Indiana University Purdue University Fort Wayne.

Angola, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Mood Disorders
Stress
Style
Insightful
Attuned
Empowering

You are beginning an exciting internal journey toward enhanced contentment and joy! I'm honored to walk with you. Great therapy should look like a lovely conversation between friends with some amazing science and skills mixed in.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Martin McCary

Martin McCary

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
2+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Martin McCary, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Martin has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana Wesleyan University.

Munster, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Men's Issues
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Responsive
Candid
Collaborative

I am a trauma-informed therapist working with children, adolescents, and adults. I help clients navigate anxiety, depression, trauma, and family challenges. I also run a psychosocial group for teen males that enhances their ability to succeed academically, socially, and emotionally.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Emily Beal-nelis

Emily Beal-nelis

Recognized for high quality patient care

LCSW
2+ years

Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs), like Emily Beal-nelis, are social workers trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Emily has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Indiana University Purdue University Indianapolis.

Waldron, IN
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Stress
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Practical
Spiritual
Motivational

Let's be real.... If you are finding yourself here, it's not because things are great. I strive to create a space for you to feel completely safe to talk about what you're struggling with, whether that be anxiety, grief, trauma, depression, work, or relationship issues.

Available virtually

Continue exploring providers