Connect with Therapists who accept CareFirst in Erie, OH

Quality care comes first at Rula

We regularly review providers to ensure quality

50+ therapists
A headshot image of Tabatha Sapene

Tabatha Sapene

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LISW-S
16+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Tabatha Sapene, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Tabatha has a Master of Science in Social Work, Clinical Concentration from The Ohio State University.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Stress
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Spiritual
Collaborative

I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker Supervisor (LISW-S). I work with adults and adolescents. I specialize in anxiety, stress, generational trauma, and mind, body, emotion, and spiritual balance using Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Mindfulness, and other modalities to help my clients make progress towards being the best version of themselves.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Michelle Laver

Michelle Laver

LISW
7+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Michelle Laver, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Michelle has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Eastern Michigan University.

Grand Rapids, OH
Specialties
Adoption
Anxiety
Autism or Asperger's Syndrome
Stress
Style
Responsive
Gentle
Collaborative

I work with adults and specialize in trauma, anxiety, and stress disorders. I use Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, and various other therapies to help my clients become their best selves.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Sherryl Lindsey

Sherryl Lindsey

Many new patients continue care with this provider

2+ years

Sherryl has a Master of Arts in Counseling Psychology from Santa Clara University.

Dayton, OH
Specialties
Life Transitions
Relationship Issues
Style
Insightful
Attuned
Curious

I specialize in relationship issues and am passionate about helping people overcome obstacles and challenges. My approach consists of a variety of strategies tailored to the issues you present to me, empowering you to create meaningful change in your life.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Iris Pfeffer

Iris Pfeffer

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW
13+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Iris Pfeffer, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Iris has a Master of Science in Social Work (MSSW) from San Diego State University.

Hamilton, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Bipolar Disorder
Depression
Personality Disorders
Style
Outcome-oriented
Gentle
Collaborative

I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker who brings a wealth of experience and compassion to the individuals, couples, and groups that I serve. My career continues to open new vistas with study, new experiences, and consultation with colleagues.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Emmaly Diller

Emmaly Diller

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW
6+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Emmaly Diller, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Emmaly has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Cincinnati.

Milford, OH
Specialties
Grief
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Outcome-oriented
Warm
Supportive

I work with people navigating difficult life events or searching for meaning and purpose. Whether you're facing challenges in relationships, struggling with painful emotions, or seeking clarity about your path forward, I'm here to help. My approach is grounded in respect, compassion, and the belief that change is possible.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Melanie Genova

Melanie Genova

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW-S
14+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Melanie Genova, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Melanie has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Akron.

Youngstown, OH
Specialties
Adoption
Anxiety
Relationship Issues
Spirituality
Style
Insightful
Candid
Curious

I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker. I approach therapy from an attachment theory and a cognitive-behavioral approach. I have worked in social services with individuals and families since 1995. I have served through outpatient counseling since 2010. I specialize in counseling individuals, couples, and families.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Sherrie Kleinholz

Sherrie Kleinholz

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LPCC
10+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Sherrie Kleinholz, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sherrie has a Master in Counseling (MC) from Xavier University.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Stress
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Insightful
Spiritual
Curious

I am a LPCC‑S and LMHC who takes a collaborative, client‑driven approach to therapy. I specialize in OCD, panic disorder, mood disorders, and general mental health concerns. My style is practical, compassionate, and rooted in evidence‑based care. I am also able to provide Christian/Catholic perspectives if you so desire.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Evelyn Clark

Evelyn Clark

LPCC
10+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Evelyn Clark, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Evelyn has a Master of Science (MS) in Education from Youngstown State University.

Youngstown, OH
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Substance Use
Style
Practical
Spiritual
Affirming

Life these days can be difficult to navigate, especially when we consider all that we need to place our focus on. Relationships, child-rearing, finances, job stress, and life transitions can cause a huge amount of distress and, at times, may seem overwhelming when we don't have the skills necessary to navigate through them, but there is hope!

Available virtually

A headshot image of Kellie Cousino

Kellie Cousino

LISW
4+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Kellie Cousino, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Kellie has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Eastern Michigan University.

Ohio
Specialties
Addiction
Alcohol Use
Anxiety
Bipolar Disorder
Substance Use
Style
Outcome-oriented
Approachable
Motivational

I have worked in both inpatient and outpatient settings addressing mental health and substance use. I am passionate about helping clients achieve their goals.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Cary Sanders

Cary Sanders

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LPCC
28+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Cary Sanders, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Cary has a Master of Education (MED) from Kent State University.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
LGBTQIA+
Relationship Issues
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Insightful
Approachable
Collaborative

I look forward to learning your stories, helping you recognize your strengths, and together finding tools to allow you to reach your goals. I have been able to support individuals who have struggled with trauma (including sexual trauma), self-worth and identity questions, anxiety, depression, relationship issues, and adjustment to difficulties.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Stephanie Emmons

Stephanie Emmons

LISW-S
3+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Stephanie Emmons, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Stephanie has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Kentucky.

Portsmouth, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Coping Skills
Depression
Grief
Mood Disorders
Style
Outcome-oriented
Attuned
Collaborative

I offer individual and couples psychotherapy. I specialize in anxiety and depression and have experience with grief and bereavement. I try to make myself available on weekends and evenings to accommodate clients. I am a psychotherapist at a VA clinic located in OH, which also gives me experience in trauma, bipolar and other mental health diagnoses.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Rhonda Farley

Rhonda Farley

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LISW
1+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Rhonda Farley, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Rhonda has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Walden University.

Ohio
Specialties
ADHD
Anxiety
Life Transitions
Style
Responsive
Warm
Curious

I work with adolescents and adults who are navigating anxiety, depression, ADHD, Autism Spectrum Disorder, life transitions, and self-esteem challenges. I use Cognitive Behavioral Therapy and a Client-Centered Approach to help my clients progress and feel better.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Ellise Cook

Ellise Cook

LISW
3+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Ellise Cook, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Ellise has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Cincinnati College of Medicine.

Hamilton, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Trauma and PTSD
Women's Issues
Style
Practical
Attuned
Empowering

I've been dedicated to supporting individuals through outpatient therapy. I focus on both mental health and substance abuse and have experience in treating PTSD, anxiety, depression, ADHD, OCD, BPD, and substance abuse.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Nicole Fogel

Nicole Fogel

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LISW
2+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Nicole Fogel, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Nicole has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from New York University, School of Social Work.

Hilliard, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Career Counseling
Depression
Relationship Issues
Style
Directive
Candid
Motivational

Counseling and coaching have been passions of mine for quite some time. My ideal client is anyone looking for direction and guidance. Do you have questions about your career, relationship, parenting skills, or the direction of your life? We will design an individualized plan that suits you.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Lynn Sobonya

Lynn Sobonya

Recognized for high quality patient care

LPCC
1+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Lynn Sobonya, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Lynn has a Master of Education (MED) in Chemical Dependency Counseling Certificate /Clinical Mental Health Counseling Program from Cleveland State University.

Parma, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Stress
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Directive
Candid
Supportive

Congratulations on taking the first step toward personal growth and living more fulfilled! I prefer an integrative approach that addresses your holistic well-being: mind, body, and spirit.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Kelsey McGrail

Kelsey McGrail

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW
9+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Kelsey McGrail, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Kelsey has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Ohio State University.

Columbus, OH
Specialties
ADHD
Anxiety
Depression
Obsessive-Compulsive (OCD)
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Outcome-oriented
Gentle
Collaborative

I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker with a supervisory designation based in Columbus, OH, and I work with clients statewide via telehealth. I work with children, adolescents, and adults experiencing anxiety, depression, ADHD, OCD, and PTSD, using a combination of CBT, DBT, Solution-Focused/Strength-Based, and trauma-sensitive approaches.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Stephanie Castle

Stephanie Castle

Recognized for high quality patient care

LP
34+ years

Licensed Psychologists (LPs), like Stephanie Castle, hold a doctoral degree and are trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Stephanie has a Doctor of Philosophy (PHD) from Ohio University and a Master of Science (MS) from University of Dayton.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Stress
Style
Practical
Gentle
Collaborative

I provide therapy to adults and specialize in treating anxiety, depression, and stress-related symptoms.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Ashley D. Harper, MSW, LISW-S

Ashley D. Harper, MSW, LISW-S

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LISW
2+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Ashley D. Harper, MSW, LISW-S, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Ashley D. has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from The Ohio State University.

Ohio
Specialties
Mood Disorders
Personality Disorders
Relationship Issues
Sex Therapy
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Practical
Candid
Motivational

I’m an Ohio Licensed Independent Social Worker-Supervisor (LISW-S) with advanced training in sex therapy. I provide trauma-informed, sex-positive care using CBT, DBT, mindfulness, and strengths-based approaches, with a focus on trauma/PTSD, anxiety, mood concerns, relationships, intimacy, and sexual wellness.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Jennifer Scholl

Jennifer Scholl

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW-S
3+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Jennifer Scholl, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Jennifer has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Ohio State University College of Social Work.

Columbus, OH
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
LGBTQIA+
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Insightful
Approachable
Affirming

Welcome! I am a licensed independent social worker. I have been in the social work field since 2009 and earned my MSW in 2018. I'm currently looking for new EMDR clients while I work towards certification. I take a supportive, affirming stance in therapy. I will guide you to a healthier life, but at your pace.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Stephanie Sanders

Stephanie Sanders

Recognized for high quality patient care

LPCC
23+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Stephanie Sanders, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Stephanie has a Master's in Counseling (MC) in Community Counseling from University of Akron.

Akron, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Older Adult
Relationship Issues
Style
Responsive
Approachable
Collaborative

As a Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor and Certified Advanced Grief Specialist, I believe healing begins with truly being seen, heard and accepted. I strive to create a safe, authentic, and nonjudgmental space where clients can openly share experiences, feelings and challenges without fear of judgement or shame.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Sandy Sickles

Sandy Sickles

Recognized for high quality patient care

LPCC
13+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Sandy Sickles, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sandy has a Masters of Education (MED) from Ohio University.

Athens, OH
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Stress
Style
Responsive
Approachable
Motivational

I create a supportive and nonjudgmental space where you feel empowered to explore your thoughts and emotions. I work with adults and adolescents dealing with anxiety, depression, trauma, life transitions, and stress management. My goal is to help you feel heard, valued, and equipped to navigate life's challenges with confidence and resilience.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Taylor Williams

Taylor Williams

Recognized for high quality patient care

LPCC
5+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Taylor Williams, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Taylor has a Master's in Counseling (MC) from Heidelberg University.

Columbus, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Borderline Personality
Depression
LGBTQIA+
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Responsive
Attuned
Supportive

I believe everyone is unique, and therapy should fit their individual needs. I draw from trauma-informed care, DBT, CBT, and other modalities. I also keep therapy human—celebrating small wins, laughing when needed, and finding creative ways to make the work feel less overwhelming.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Cynthia Holloway

Cynthia Holloway

Recognized for high quality patient care

15+ years

Cynthia has a Master of Science (MS) from Butler University.

Troy, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Mood Disorders
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Insightful
Attuned
Collaborative

I look forward to helping you heal and develop skills that will help you help yourself.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Alyce Fortnoff

Alyce Fortnoff

LPCC
27+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Alyce Fortnoff, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Alyce has a Master in Counseling (MC) from University of Akron.

Akron, OH
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Responsive
Approachable
Supportive

Most of my clients are between the ages of 20-75. My focus is working with clients to individualize their needs and find solutions as well as a sense of well-being.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Stevie Lamblin

Stevie Lamblin

LPCC
2+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Stevie Lamblin, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Stevie has a Master of Science (MS) in Clinical mental Health Cnsl from Wright State University.

Ohio
Specialties
Bipolar Disorder
LGBTQIA+
Mood Disorders
Personality Disorders
Style
Practical
Warm
Collaborative

I have additional certification in Dialectical Behavior Therapy. I primarily work with mood disorders, personality disorders, LGBTQ populations, and life adjustments and transitions.

Available virtually

Continue exploring providers