Connect with Therapists who accept Aetna in Middletown, OH

Quality care comes first at Rula

We regularly review providers to ensure quality

50+ therapists
A headshot image of Mary Jo Butler Fingerhut

Mary Jo Butler Fingerhut

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Mary Jo Butler Fingerhut, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Mary Jo has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Southern California.

Hamilton, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Outcome-oriented
Gentle
Motivational

Congratulations on taking this step toward creating or reinforcing the life you want to live. I strive to provide a safe and supportive environment where you feel comfortable being open and honest. I look forward to collaborating with you using a client-centered approach to achieve the best possible outcomes.

Available virtually and in person

A headshot image of Michael Spitz

Michael Spitz

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LISW

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Michael Spitz, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Michael has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Loyola University/Chicago.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Mood Disorders
Stress
Style
Directive
Approachable
Collaborative

Is your child becoming more depressed, anxious, or defiant? Are you uncertain about where to go from here? I work with children, teenagers, and adults to follow their passions and manage stressors without letting mental health challenges hinder them. I have a good sense of humor and work in a relaxed, informal manner.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Hicks Barbara

Hicks Barbara

Many new patients continue care with this provider

LISW

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Hicks Barbara, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Hicks has a Master of Science in Social Work (MSSW) from University of Louisville.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Self Esteem
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Directive
Gentle
Collaborative

You don't have to be defined by what you've been through. EMDR is a proven therapy for overcoming the distress of past trauma. Unlike traditional talk therapy, EMDR helps your brain's natural healing process to unstick and reprocess traumatic memories.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Iris Pfeffer

Iris Pfeffer

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW
40+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Iris Pfeffer, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Iris has a Master of Science in Social Work (MSSW) from San Diego State University and a Bachelor of Social Work (BSW) from Rochester Institute of Technology.

Hamilton, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Bipolar Disorder
Depression
Personality Disorders
Style
Outcome-oriented
Gentle
Collaborative

I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker who brings a wealth of experience and compassion to the individuals, couples, and groups that I serve. My career continues to open new vistas with study, new experiences, and consultation with colleagues.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Sarah McCall

Sarah McCall

LISW

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Sarah McCall, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Sarah has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from The Ohio State University College of Social Work.

Ohio
Specialties
Life Transitions
School Issues
Stress
Trauma and PTSD
Women's Issues
Style
Insightful
Approachable
Motivational

If you’re tired of holding it all together while quietly feeling overwhelmed, anxious, burned out, or stuck, you’re in the right place. I help clients navigate life’s hardest moments, reconnect with who they are, and create meaningful change through warm, honest, collaborative therapy.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Johnathon Redmon

Johnathon Redmon

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW
2+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Johnathon Redmon, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Johnathon has a Master of Science in Social Work (MSSW) from Ohio State University.

Findlay, OH
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Substance Use
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Gentle
Collaborative

I believe in a person-centered approach when it comes to therapy, with a history of working with people experiencing intense mental health and addiction problems.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Molly Propst

Molly Propst

LPCC

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Molly Propst, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Molly has a Master of Science (MS) addictions counseling from Texas Tech University, Health Science Center.

Ohio
Specialties
ADHD
Autism or Asperger's Syndrome
Eating Disorders
Transgender Issues
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Approachable
Affirming

When I’m not working, you can find me reading, spending time with my pets, traveling with my partner, or trying a new coffee shop. I believe in a collaborative approach that honors your unique neurotype and identity, helping you reconnect with your strength at a pace that feels safe for you.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Michelle Spangenberg

Michelle Spangenberg

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW
3+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Michelle Spangenberg, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Michelle has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Campbellsville University.

Cincinnati, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Responsive
Attuned
Empowering

I work with teens and adults struggling with anxiety, depression, PTSD, and life transitions. I've spent years providing crisis care to children, teens, and families, and working with adults facing complex mental health challenges. When I'm not in session, I'm spending time with my family and planning my next adventure.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Marni Tartack

Marni Tartack

LISW

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Marni Tartack, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Marni has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Widener University.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Older Adult
Stress
Style
Responsive
Gentle
Collaborative

I'm a Licensed Clinical Social Worker who helps adults manage anxiety, depression, stress, life transitions, and other challenges that affect daily life. I provide a supportive, compassionate space where we can work together to build coping skills and create meaningful change.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Anthony Watt

Anthony Watt

Recognized for high quality patient care

LPCC
2+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Anthony Watt, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Anthony has a Masters of Education (MED) in Clinical Counseling from Malone University.

Ohio
Specialties
ADHD
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Men's Issues
Style
Directive
Approachable
Collaborative

I am a Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor and Licensed Independent Chemical Dependency Counselor. I specialize in helping individuals navigate anxiety, ADHD, trauma, addiction, and men’s mental health. Whether you’re feeling stuck, overwhelmed, or looking for real strategies to create change, I provide practical, action-based therapy.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Sherrie Kleinholz

Sherrie Kleinholz

Recognized for high quality patient care

LPCC
10+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Sherrie Kleinholz, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Sherrie has a Master in Counseling (MC) from Xavier University.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Stress
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Insightful
Spiritual
Curious

I am a LPCC‑S and LMHC who takes a collaborative, client‑driven approach to therapy. I specialize in OCD, panic disorder, mood disorders, and general mental health concerns. My style is practical, compassionate, and rooted in evidence‑based care. I am also able to provide Christian/Catholic perspectives if you so desire.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Cassandra Martin-Weiler

Cassandra Martin-Weiler

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW-S
4+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Cassandra Martin-Weiler, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Cassandra has a Doctor of Behavioral Health in Guidance and Counseling from University of Education - Winneba and a Master of Social Work (MSW) in Clinical Social Work and Urban Studies from Michigan State University.

Pataskala, OH
Specialties
Anger Management
Anxiety
Depression
Self Esteem
Stress
Style
Exploratory
Gentle
Collaborative

I have experience in various therapeutic settings and am passionate about helping clients navigate their mental health journeys.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Tanisha Richardson

Tanisha Richardson

LISW-S

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Tanisha Richardson, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Tanisha has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Walden University and a Masters of Arts (MA) in Humanities from Tiffin University.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Cultural Stress
Depression
Grief
Stress
Style
Responsive
Approachable
Affirming

I am devoted to those who want to improve their mental health. I support and guide individuals who are facing mental anguish. Together we develop a restorative approach through interventions, tailored coping techniques, and personalized methods that move you forward.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Renee Leber

Renee Leber

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Renee Leber, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Renee has a Master of Science in Social Administration (MSSA) from Case Western Reserve University.

Berlin Heights, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Life Transitions
Mood Disorders
Self Esteem
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Responsive
Warm
Empowering

Whether this is your first time exploring therapy or you're returning after a break, I welcome you. I cultivate a relaxed, grounded atmosphere in sessions. Grab tea at your kitchen table, curl up on your couch, or go outside for a walk. Therapy should feel like a space where you can exhale and just be.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Christina Wynkoop

Christina Wynkoop

LPCC
5+ years

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Christina Wynkoop, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Christina has a Master in Counseling (MC) from Methodist Theological School in Ohio.

Delaware, OH
Specialties
ADHD
Anxiety
Depression
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Outcome-oriented
Gentle
Supportive

I have had experience and training in working with clients who have a history of trauma, depression, anxiety, childhood disorders, teenage issues, and family systems.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Cute Lee

Cute Lee

Recognized for high quality patient care

LPCC

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Cute Lee, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Cute has a Master of Arts (MA) in Counseling from Assemblies of God Theological Seminary.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Life Transitions
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Approachable
Collaborative

I believe deeply in the power of connection, culturally responsive care, and building systems that truly uplift communities. Whether leading a team or supporting a client, my mission is to create spaces where people feel seen, valued, and empowered to live fully.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Amanda Nowman

Amanda Nowman

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW-S
3+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Amanda Nowman, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Amanda has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Ohio State University College of Social Work.

Piqua, OH
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Bipolar Disorder
Depression
Substance Use
Style
Responsive
Spiritual
Motivational

I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker with supervisory designation and a Licensed Independent Chemical Dependency Counselor, providing therapy services. My background includes working with adolescent, adult, and geriatric clients to address concerns related to substance use, depression, anxiety, bipolar disorder, and many other conditions.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Kelsey McGrail

Kelsey McGrail

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW
9+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Kelsey McGrail, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Kelsey has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Ohio State University.

Columbus, OH
Specialties
ADHD
Anxiety
Depression
Obsessive-Compulsive (OCD)
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Outcome-oriented
Gentle
Collaborative

I am a Licensed Independent Social Worker with a supervisory designation based in Columbus, OH, and I work with clients statewide via telehealth. I work with children, adolescents, and adults experiencing anxiety, depression, ADHD, OCD, and PTSD, using a combination of CBT, DBT, Solution-Focused/Strength-Based, and trauma-sensitive approaches.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Bethany Putnam

Bethany Putnam

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Bethany Putnam, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Bethany has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Cincinnati.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Grief
Life Transitions
Self Esteem
Stress
Style
Outcome-oriented
Approachable
Supportive

Let’s be honest: does anyone have it all together? From 18 to 81, life gets overwhelming. As a mom and therapist who has navigated the trenches, I offer a space where you don't need all the answers. Whether you’re a college student navigating life, a parent in the thick of it, or a caregiver supporting a loved one, let's find your footing.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Emmaly Diller

Emmaly Diller

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW
6+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Emmaly Diller, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Emmaly has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Cincinnati.

Milford, OH
Specialties
Grief
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Outcome-oriented
Warm
Supportive

I work with people navigating difficult life events or searching for meaning and purpose. Whether you're facing challenges in relationships, struggling with painful emotions, or seeking clarity about your path forward, I'm here to help. My approach is grounded in respect, compassion, and the belief that change is possible.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Rhonda Farley

Rhonda Farley

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW
18+ years

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Rhonda Farley, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Rhonda has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from Walden University.

Ohio
Specialties
ADHD
Anxiety
Life Transitions
Style
Responsive
Warm
Curious

I work with adolescents and adults who are navigating anxiety, depression, ADHD, Autism Spectrum Disorder, life transitions, and self-esteem challenges. I use Cognitive Behavioral Therapy and a Client-Centered Approach to help my clients progress and feel better.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Joseph Earl

Joseph Earl

Recognized for high quality patient care

LPCC

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Joseph Earl, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Joseph has a Master in Counseling (MC) Clinical Mental Health Counseling from Liberty University.

Ohio
Specialties
Addiction
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Style
Exploratory
Spiritual
Collaborative

Beginning therapy can seem scary and overwhelming. I am grateful you are exploring the courage needed to travel this part of your journey. I work within a Christian-based collaborative structure, which means God is invited as we explore anxiety, depression, grief, addiction, trauma, or simply feeling overwhelmed by current situations.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Holly Dobias

Holly Dobias

LISW

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Holly Dobias, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Holly has a Master of Science in Social Administration (MSSA) from Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine.

Ohio
Specialties
Child Abuse or Neglect
Chronic Illness
Coping Skills
Family Conflict
Style
Directive
Approachable
Affirming

I'm so glad you made the decision to start your therapy journey! I am an LISW (Licensed Social Worker) in the state of Ohio. My goal is to create a safe space for clients to explore life topics and foster personal growth.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Joseph Ombrello

Joseph Ombrello

Recognized for high quality patient care

LPCC

Licensed Professional Clinical Counselors (LPCCs), like Joseph Ombrello, are mental health professionals trained to diagnose and treat mental health issues and substance misuse with psychotherapy and counseling.

Joseph has a Masters of Science in Education (MS ED) Master of Education Human Relations from Northern Arizona University.

Ohio
Specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Self Esteem
Spirituality
Trauma and PTSD
Style
Exploratory
Candid
Empowering

I’m a licensed professional clinical counselor who works primarily with adults, veterans, and first responders, focusing on anxiety, trauma, and substance use. My practice is practical and skills-based, using CBT, REBT, mindfulness, and behavioral strategies to help clients build autonomy, resilience, and real-world functioning.

Available virtually

A headshot image of Erin Flora

Erin Flora

Recognized for high quality patient care

LISW

Licensed Independent Social Workers (LISWs), like Erin Flora, are social workers trained to provide psychotherapy and counseling.

Erin has a Master of Social Work (MSW) from University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee.

Columbus, OH
Specialties
Anxiety
Chronic Illness
Depression
Style
Insightful
Candid
Supportive

I am looking forward to meeting you. I have experience working in health care as a clinical social worker at trauma hospitals. I am an empathetic and kind person who is interested in helping you work through a new struggle or overcome an obstacle. I am an LISW-S.

Available virtually

Continue exploring providers