Hindsight bias is the “knew-it-all-along” effect that makes us think that we accurately predicted outcomes after the fact, even when that wasn’t really the case.
Most people experience hindsight bias once in a while. It’s usually the brain’s way of helping us feel safe, affirming our beliefs, and making sense of the world.
However, frequent hindsight bias can skew your perception of the past and make it harder to embrace possibility. If needed, therapy can help you explore your biases and see the past, present, and future more accurately.
Have you ever had the sense that after something happened, you knew what the outcome would be all along? If so, you may have experienced the psychological phenomenon known as hindsight bias. Hindsight bias occurs when a person overestimates their ability to predict an outcome accurately.
Research suggests that hindsight bias is common across age groups and cultures. If you experience it occasionally, it’s not necessarily cause for concern. On its own, hindsight bias isn’t a psychological problem or a sign of a mental health concern.
However, if it happens frequently, it might be something to explore. In some cases, misjudging the past could reduce your ability to predict future harm. Fortunately, learning more about hindsight bias can help you keep the “knew-it-all-along” effect in check.
Where the “knew-it-all-along” effect comes from
You may experience hindsight bias in many different ways. But here are some examples to help you understand how it might occur in real life.
You’re watching your favorite football team play in the final game of the season. The scores are tied, but at the last second, your team scores a touchdown and wins the game. You have an immediate sense of, “I knew it!” almost as if you didn’t believe for a second your team could lose.
After hearing the results of a local election, you’re disappointed but unsurprised. Looking back at the campaign, it seems like it was almost inevitable that the candidate you voted for would lose.
When you get to the end of a murder mystery novel, there’s a surprise plot twist. But the more you think about it, the more you realize you knew exactly who the killer was all along.
If you can relate to any of these examples, you’re not alone. Hindsight bias can make past events seem predictable, even when they weren’t. We aren’t yet entirely sure where this tendency comes from.
But research suggests that it might be related to some of the brain’s protective strategies:
Cognitive: People tend to revise their memories to align with what they now believe to be true. They also tend to forget or misremember facts that challenge what seems true in the present.
Example: When your favorite football team scored at the last second, you instantly forgot about the doubts you had during the first half of the game. It felt like you had been completely confident in your team the entire time.
Metacognitive: If a person can easily understand why something happened, it can seem inevitable (even if it wasn’t).
Example: Upon seeing the disappointing election results, you thought about how poorly your candidate did during the last debate. Suddenly, it made total sense that they lost because they couldn’t connect with their constituents.
Motivational: People tend to feel safer when things seem orderly and predictable. Acknowledging that things can happen at random and without warning can make a person feel uncomfortably vulnerable.
Example: Feeling that you accurately predicted that final plot twist in the novel you were reading might make you think you could do the same thing in real life.
The care you need, when you need it
Learn how Rula can support your mental health journey
The emotional impact of hindsight bias
Occasional hindsight bias isn’t necessarily problematic. However, if it happens all the time, it can take a toll on your mental health and emotional well-being. Having false certainty about outcomes may warp your perceptions in unhelpful ways.
Over time, this can lead to:
Overconfidence: Feeling like you can confidently predict the future could detract from your ability to make sound decisions for yourself and others.
Risky behavior: If you think you always know what will happen next, you might take unnecessary risks. For example, you might quit your job before having another one lined up if you mistakenly think you’ll be hired immediately.
Victim blaming: If harm seems completely predictable, you might risk blaming victims for what happened to them. For example, if your neighbor’s house gets robbed, you might think it was their fault for not taking steps to prevent it.
Hindsight bias isn’t an official symptom of a clinical mental health condition. But it has been loosely associated with depression. Interestingly, depression is also linked with bias more broadly. Research suggests that bias may result from or worsen depression because it makes it more difficult to integrate new beliefs or experiences — especially positive ones.
How to avoid misjudging the past
Understanding how hindsight bias works can help you become more self-aware, thoughtful in your decision-making, and comfortable with uncertainty. If you find yourself frequently misjudging the past, explore these tips:
Log the evidence
If the outcome of an event felt inevitable, it might be because of hindsight bias. Regardless of what ultimately occurred, write down a list of other things that could have happened. Then, being as objective as possible, write down anything that could have caused those different outcomes.
This exercise can help you realize when you may have experienced hindsight bias in the past, so you can be on the lookout for it in the future.
Be kind to yourself
Sometimes, hindsight bias brings up feelings of guilt or shame. For example, maybe you feel like you let your family down because you lost your job. Your hindsight bias might say, “Well, of course that happened.
You weren’t qualified for that job in the first place!” even when that’s objectively untrue.
In those moments, try to remind yourself that not everything is your fault and there’s only so much you can control. Try to treat yourself with the same kindness you’d show a friend in a similar situation.
Ask for help
If hindsight bias is affecting your mental health, know that you’re not alone, and help is available. Therapy can provide a safe space to explore your biases, navigate uncertainty, and embrace possibility in the future.
When you catch yourself thinking, ‘I should’ve known,’ remind yourself that you made the best choice you could with what you knew at the time. Showing compassion for your past self helps you move forward instead of staying stuck.
Brandy Chalmers, LPC
Clinical reviewer
Find care with Rula
Hindsight bias is a psychological phenomenon that gives us the sense that we predicted an outcome accurately, even when that wasn’t really the case. On its own, hindsight bias isn’t a sign of a mental health condition, but when it happens all the time, it can skew your perceptions and negatively impact your mental health. If you need support navigating your biases, talking to a therapist can help.
At Rula, we’re committed to delivering a comprehensive behavioral health experience that helps people feel seen and understood so they can get back to feeling their best.
Rula makes it easier to find a licensed therapist or psychiatric provider who accepts your insurance so you don’t have to choose between affordable care and excellent care. With a diverse network of more than 15,000 providers, 24/7 crisis support, and appointments available as soon as tomorrow, we're here to help you make progress — wherever you are on your mental health journey.
Liz Talago
Liz Talago, M.ed. is a mental health professional turned content writer and strategist based in the Detroit metro area. As an independent consultant for mental health organizations, Liz creates meaningful connections between brands and their audiences through strategic storytelling. Liz is known for championing diverse perspectives within the mental health industry and translating bold ideas into inspiring, affirming digital experiences.
In her free time, you can find her hiking with her two German Shepherds, puttering around her dahlia garden, or spending time with her family.
Brandy Chalmers, LPC
Having faced challenges like childhood abuse, neglect, and the loss of her father to suicide, Brandy Chalmers is deeply passionate about providing compassionate care. She is a Licensed Professional Counselor, Nationally Certified Counselor, and Registered Play Therapist with a Master’s Degree in Clinical Counseling and Marriage and Family Therapy.
Brandy also teaches at a university, sharing her expertise with future mental health professionals. With over a decade of experience in settings like inpatient care and private practice, she specializes in helping clients with perfectionism, trauma, personality disorders, eating disorders, and life changes.
Rula's editorial process
Rula's editorial team is on a mission to make science-backed mental health insights accessible and practical for every person seeking to better understand or improve mental wellness.
Members of Rula’s clinical leadership team and other expert providers contribute to all published content, offering guidance on themes and insights based on their firsthand experience in the field. Every piece of content is thoroughly reviewed by a clinician before publishing.
