Every platform here takes insurance; the real difference is cost, coverage, and what care they offer. Most copays range from $0 to $50 per session, but government insurance acceptance and services like psychiatry or crisis support vary widely.
Rula patients pay an average of $15 per session and get therapy, psychiatry, and 24/7 crisis support in one platform. That's the lowest average copay among major alternatives.
Only some platforms accept Medicaid or Medicare, so government-insured readers have fewer choices. Rula and Grow Therapy offer the broadest government coverage, while platforms like SonderMind and Talkspace don't accept Medicaid at all.
Headway has the largest provider network (~80,000), but no self-pay option for the uninsured. If you're between plans or don't have insurance, you'll need to choose a platform like Rula, Alma, or Grow Therapy that offers out-of-pocket rates.
The best Headway alternatives are Rula, Grow Therapy, and Alma. Rula stands out for combining therapy and psychiatry in one insurance-based platform at about $15 a session. Grow Therapy offers wide Medicaid and Medicare acceptance. Alma provides a large hybrid network with both virtual and in-person options. SonderMind, Talkspace, and Brightside round out the strong alternatives.
People look for Headway alternatives when they need self-pay options, broader Medicaid or Medicare coverage, or prefer being matched with a therapist rather than searching on their own. Headway has a large network, roughly 80,000 providers, but it only works if you have insurance, and government coverage is limited to select managed-care plans in certain states.
This guide compares six platforms that accept insurance, offer both therapy and psychiatry, and give you a clear picture of costs before you commit to your first session.
What are the best alternatives to Headway?
Six platforms stand out as solid Headway alternatives: Rula, Grow Therapy, Alma, SonderMind, Talkspace, and Brightside. Each wins on a different dimension — cost, government insurance, network size, speed, or specialized services.
Rula offers the lowest average copay and brings therapy, psychiatry, and crisis support together in one place. Grow Therapy matches Rula's reach when it comes to Medicaid and Medicare coverage. Alma stands out for its large hybrid network, giving you the flexibility to see someone in person or online. SonderMind is built for speed; most people get their first appointment within 48 hours. Talkspace is a solid fit if you'd rather message your therapist throughout the week. And Brightside zeroes in on depression and anxiety, with dedicated crisis care when you need it most.
At-a-glance comparison table
The care you need, when you need it
Learn how Rula can support your mental health journey
Why do people look for a Headway alternative?
Headway works well for many people. It has a large provider network — roughly 80,000 therapists and psychiatrists — and offers both virtual and in-person care. But several friction points send people searching for alternatives.
First, Headway is insurance-only. If you're uninsured or between plans, there's no self-pay option. Second, it's a marketplace model: you browse and filter providers yourself rather than being matched based on your preferences.
Third, Medicaid and Medicare acceptance is limited to select managed-care plans in some states — not traditional Medicare broadly. Additionally, Headway doesn't include built-in 24/7 crisis support.
How much does each alternative cost with insurance?
When you use insurance, you pay a copay — the amount you owe after your plan covers its share. That's typically much lower than the full "sticker price" you'd pay without coverage.
According to Mental Health America (citing SAMHSA's 2023 NSDUH), 59.80% of adults who went without mental healthcare said cost was a barrier. And insurance-based platforms close that gap by bringing your per-session cost down to a manageable copay.
Here's what you'll actually pay with insurance across the major platforms:
Rula: average $15 per session
Talkspace: $10–$30 per session with insurance
Brightside: $15–$30 per session with insurance
Grow Therapy: average about $21 per session
SonderMind: average about $25 per session
Headway: $0–$35 per session
Most platforms charge per session. However, Talkspace and Brightside use subscription models, so if you're paying out of pocket, you'll pay a weekly or monthly fee. Before you book, ask for a cost estimate so you know exactly what to expect.
The care you need, when you need it
Learn how Rula can support your mental health journey
Which alternatives accept Medicaid and Medicare?
If you're on Medicaid or Medicare, your options narrow quickly, as not every online therapy platform accepts government insurance. Here's how government coverage breaks down across these platforms:
Rula: Medicare in all 50 states; Medicaid in select states. The broadest government coverage among major platforms, including Medicare-covered care for psychiatry.
Grow Therapy: Medicare and Medicaid in select states.
Brightside: Medicare; Medicaid in select plans.
Headway: Select Medicare Advantage plans and select Medicaid managed-care plans in some states.
SonderMind: Medicare; no Medicaid.
Talkspace: Medicare; no Medicaid.
Alma: No standalone Medicaid; Medicare only through Optum Advantage or dual-eligible plans.
Rula and Grow Therapy offer the widest government-plan coverage among these alternatives.
The 6 best Headway alternatives
The platforms below are ordered by breadth of coverage and overall value. The right choice depends on your needs, including your insurance, whether you need psychiatry, and whether you want couples or family care.
1. Rula — best all-in-one insurance-based care
Services offered: Individual, couples, and family therapy; psychiatry; 24/7 crisis support
Insurance acceptance: 170 commercial plans; Medicare in all 50 states; Medicaid in select states
Pricing: Average $15 per session with insurance; self-pay from $150 (therapy) / $225 psychiatry intake
Rula brings online therapy through insurance, psychiatry, and crisis support together in one coordinated platform. Most online platforms handle only one of these services. Rula keeps them connected so your care team can actually work together.
Before your first session, Rula verifies your insurance and gives you a cost estimate upfront. The platform shows you profiles that fit what you're looking for, and you can filter by gender, language, identity, specialty, availability, and treatment approach.
Rula also tracks outcomes. Most patients start feeling better after about four sessions. 93% of individuals receiving treatment through Rula experienced improvement in their symptoms, with Rula's clinical results exceeding those of comparable platforms by more than 10% on average.
If these differences matter to you, our Rula versus Headway breakdown shows them side by side so you can make an informed decision about your care.
2. Grow Therapy — best for Medicaid and Medicare acceptance
Services offered: Individual, couples, family, and teen therapy; psychiatry
Insurance acceptance: 100+ commercial plans; Medicare; Medicaid in select states
Pricing: Average about $21 per session with insurance; self-pay $75–$250
Grow Therapy matches Rula's government-insurance breadth, accepting both Medicare and Medicaid in select states, which makes it one of the strongest options if you're on a government plan and want in-network care.
Most people get their first appointment within about two days, and the platform uses a marketplace model that lets you browse profiles and choose your own provider based on specialty, availability, and approach. You'll have the flexibility to meet virtually or in person, depending on what works better for your schedule and preferences.
One thing to keep in mind: because Grow operates as a marketplace, costs and plan acceptance can vary by individual provider, so it's worth confirming your specific copay and coverage before you book.
3. Alma — best large hybrid network
Services offered: Individual, couples, and family therapy; psychiatry
Insurance acceptance: 30+ commercial plans; no standalone Medicaid; Medicare only via Optum Advantage/dual-eligible
Pricing: Copay varies with insurance; self-pay $80–$380
Alma operates one of the larger hybrid networks in the space, with more than 24,000 therapists and psychiatrists available for both in-person and virtual sessions. That size gives you real flexibility when you're looking for someone who fits your needs — whether that's a specific specialty, treatment approach, or simply an office close to home. Most people can book their first appointment within about three days, which puts Alma in the middle of the pack for speed.
The main limitation is insurance coverage. Alma doesn't accept standalone Medicaid at all, and its Medicare acceptance is narrow, limited to specific Optum Advantage plans or dual-eligible arrangements. If you're on traditional Medicare or a state Medicaid program, you'll likely need to pay out of pocket, and Alma's self-pay rates range from $80 to $380 per session depending on the provider and service type.
4. SonderMind — best for fast scheduling
Services offered: Individual, couples, and family therapy; psychiatry
Insurance acceptance: Most major commercial plans; Medicare; no Medicaid
Pricing: $0-$55 per session with insurance; self-pay $45–$183
SonderMind is built around speed. Most people book their first session within 48 hours, which makes it one of the fastest options if you're looking to start care right away. The platform offers video, phone, and in-person appointments, though in-person availability depends on your location and tends to be stronger in larger metro areas.
The trade-off is coverage. SonderMind's provider network is denser in urban markets, so if you're in a rural area or smaller town, you may find fewer options or longer wait times. The platform also doesn't accept Medicaid at all, which rules it out for anyone on state insurance. Medicare is accepted, but if you're on Medicaid or live outside a major city, Rula or Grow Therapy will likely give you better access to in-network providers who can see you quickly.
5. Talkspace — best for messaging-based therapy
Services offered: Individual, couples, and teen therapy; psychiatry
Insurance acceptance: Most major commercial plans; Medicare; no Medicaid
Pricing: $10–$30 per session with insurance; self-pay $69–$109/week; psychiatry $175–$299
Talkspace takes a different approach by combining asynchronous text messaging with scheduled video sessions, which works well if you prefer the flexibility to reach out to your therapist throughout the week rather than waiting for your next appointment. You can send messages whenever something comes up, get responses within the day, and still schedule live video sessions when you need real-time support. This hybrid model appeals to people who want ongoing access without feeling locked into a rigid weekly schedule.
Unlike most platforms on this list, Talkspace auto-assigns your therapist at signup based on your intake questionnaire rather than letting you browse profiles and choose. There's no in-person option at all, which rules it out if you prefer face-to-face sessions. The platform also doesn't accept Medicaid, and its psychiatry service won't prescribe controlled substances.
6. Brightside Health — best for depression, anxiety, and crisis care
Services offered: Individual therapy; psychiatry; dedicated crisis care program
Insurance acceptance: Most major commercial plans; Medicare; Medicaid in select plans
Pricing: $15–$30 per session with insurance; self-pay $95–$349/month
Brightside focuses specifically on depression and anxiety, which means the platform is built around evidence-based treatments for those two conditions rather than trying to cover every mental health concern. That narrow focus allows Brightside to offer a dedicated Crisis Care program for people who need higher-touch support during difficult moments. The platform moves combines therapy with psychiatry so you can access both talk therapy and medication management if needed.
The trade-offs are format and scope. Brightside is virtual-only, with no in-person option, and it uses a subscription model rather than per-session billing. That can work well if you want predictable monthly costs and the flexibility to message your provider between sessions, but it also means you're paying whether you use all your sessions or not.
Who should choose which alternative?
The right platform depends on what you need most, whether that's government insurance acceptance, psychiatry, couples care, or the ability to pay out of pocket. Once you know your priorities, the choice becomes clearer. Here's how to match your situation to the strongest option:
Medicaid or Medicare: Rula, Grow Therapy, or Brightside offer the strongest government coverage if you're on a government plan.
Psychiatry or medication management: Rula, SonderMind, Talkspace, and Brightside all offer psychiatry alongside therapy if you need medication support.
Couples or family therapy: Rula, Grow Therapy, and Alma include couples and family services if you're looking for relationship or family care.
Want to choose your own therapist: Rula, Grow Therapy, Alma, and Headway let you browse and select your provider, while Talkspace auto-assigns a therapist.
Depression or anxiety with crisis needs: Brightside's Crisis Care program or Rula's 24/7 crisis support are built for people who need immediate help during difficult moments.
No insurance or self-pay: Alma, Grow Therapy, SonderMind, and Rula all offer self-pay rates if you're uninsured or between plans, while Headway does not.
Frequently asked questions about Headway alternatives
What is the best alternative to Headway?
Rula is the strongest all-in-one alternative, offering therapy, psychiatry, and 24/7 crisis support at an average of $15 per session. The right pick depends on your insurance and whether you need psychiatry, couples care, or Medicaid/Medicare acceptance.
Does Headway accept Medicaid and Medicare?
Headway accepts select Medicare Advantage plans and select Medicaid managed-care plans in some states. It does not broadly accept traditional Medicare or all state Medicaid programs.
Is there a Headway alternative that offers psychiatry?
Yes. Rula, Grow Therapy, SonderMind, Talkspace, and Brightside all offer psychiatry and medication management alongside therapy.
Which Headway alternative is cheapest with insurance?
Costs depend on your plan, but Rula patients pay an average of $15 per session and Talkspace copays start around $10. Most platforms fall in the $0–$50 range with insurance.
Find care with Rula
Choosing a mental health platform is about accessing care that genuinely supports your progress. Rula lets you confirm insurance coverage in minutes, explore providers with expertise in your specific concerns, and review your estimated session cost before you book. Many patients get their first appointment scheduled as early as the next day, with the flexibility to choose between virtual sessions or in-person visits.
With therapy, psychiatry, and 24/7 crisis support in one platform, Rula simplifies the process when you're ready to take the next step.
Rula Health
Rula’s editorial process
Rula’s editorial team is on a mission to make science-backed mental health insights accessible and practical for every person seeking to better understand or improve mental wellness.
Members of Rula’s clinical leadership team and other expert providers contribute to all published content, offering guidance on themes and insights based on their firsthand experience in the field. Every piece of content is thoroughly reviewed by a clinician before publishing.
